Downgraded both routers to 1.8.0. Both routers came back online and the s2s did reconnect with the same outcome.
Some how I lost my remote connection to the office so I can't log in anymore to mess with that router and troubleshoot more. I know the internet and router came back online since I can see the WIFI up and it shows the S2S link is running but for some reason my computer i was teamviewer'ing into didn't reconnect.
Oh well, keep messing with it tomorrow.