Cannot connect to OpenVPN on ERL

I recently set up OpenVPN my ERL with v1.9 firmware.

Here is my OpenVPN setup:

 openvpn vtun0 {
     description OpenVPN
     encryption aes256
     hash sha256
     mode server
     openvpn-option "--push redirect-gateway"
     openvpn-option "--push dhcp-option DNS 8.8.8.8"
     openvpn-option "--push dhcp-option DNS 8.8.4.4"
     openvpn-option --persist-tun
     openvpn-option "--port 1194"
     openvpn-option --tls-server
     openvpn-option "--comp-lzo yes"
     openvpn-option --persist-key
     openvpn-option "--keepalive 10 120"
     openvpn-option "--user nobody"
     openvpn-option "--group nogroup"
     protocol udp
     server {
         subnet 192.168.10.0/24
     }
     tls {
         ca-cert-file /config/auth/cacert.pem
         cert-file /config/auth/server.pem
         dh-file /config/auth/dhp.pem
         key-file /config/auth/server-pem.key
     }
 }

Here is my firewall rule allowing it through:

 action accept
 description OpenVPN
 destination {
     port 1194
 }
 log enable
 protocol tcp_udp
 state {
     established enable
     invalid disable
     new enable
     related enable
 }

Here is my Windows 10 client config file:

client
dev tun
proto udp
remote boulder.***.***.org 1194
cipher AES-256-CBC
auth SHA256
resolv-retry infinite
redirect-gateway def1
nobind
comp-lzo yes
persist-key
persist-tun
user nobody
group nogroup
verb 3
pkcs12 C:\\Windows\\boulder.p12

However, when I try to connect via the Windows 10 OpenVPN GUI client, it never actually connects. If I change it to TCP, it will attempt to connect, but end up timing out. With nmap, it shows 1194 on TCP and UDP being filtered, which doesn't make any sense because I have the firewall rule allowing new, established, and related connections. I'm not sure why it's not connecting.

What would cause it to fail to connect?